Return to the Gift Shop Owner and grab the Novelty-Size Key … again.
Saw a postcard returned to the Gift Shop.
Make your way through the first part of the game, which is no longer a puzzle, and collect the three Trinkets in the same location as before and return them to the Gift Shop Owner.
Saw every character's "bad ending". (Player 1 only)
Saw every character's "good ending". (Player 1 only)
Win Win Win Win Win Win Win
Took all characters to the bottom of The Cave.
Who Wants to Live Forever
Got everyone out of The Cave without dying once.