You will come across the Thief and the Merchant towards the end of the Catacombs. There are a pair of prisoners trapped in adjacent cells. Walk over and speak to one of them to learn of their predicament. Essentially we need to choose who lives and who dies and depending on your choice you will get a different reward. Saving the fellow closest to the stairs rewards you with a Trinket (Magic Leech) saving the other, will earn you the Trinket (Dim Hope) .
At the end of the Cell Circle youll find a corridor leading outside (left). As you enter, speak with one of the prisoners (right) to be told of their plight.
PC, PS4, XB One
Guide Release 7 February 2015
Last Updated 7 December 2020
Guide Author Paul Williams
Share this free guide:
Lords of the Fallen takes us on a journey to a dark and mysterious world where the lands of Keystone are under attack from an interdimensional demonic army. Join Harkyn: a branded, outcast criminal who is freed to seek his redemption through a bid to bring the invaders to their knees. Lords of the Fallen takes many of its cues and gameplay mechanics from the notoriously difficult Dark Souls series (and can be a little tricky itself at times) but puts some new and interesting spins on From Software’s winning formula.
Let us guide you through Harkyn’s adventure every step of the way. Our comprehensive guide will provide you with:
Complete walkthrough from beginning to end.
Complete list of side-quests incorporated into the main walkthrough.
Winning strategies to take down the assortment of nasty bosses.
Strategies to fight each type of enemy.
Locations of every collectible, including those found only in New Game +.
Locations of all the unique/legendary items.
Locations of every Empty Bottle and Attribute/Spell Point Shard.